BTR's staff played no role in the judging of the submitted products. Review panelists were informed that scores/comments would remain anonymous.
For the second year running, the Diamonds parlayed the vast experience of cable engineering stalwart Steve Johnson of Johnson Telecom (formerly of Time Warner Cable). Johnson spearheaded the program and recruited yet another remarkable panel of judges, who were frank and open with their opinions and eager to share their insights on these technologies and solutions. What follows are the Diamonds 2011 entries named by the judges as most worthy of the industry's careful consideration.
Judges used the following scale to determine Diamond scores:
- 0-1 Useful product, yet commodity
- 2-3 Solid product with viable attributes that set it apart
- 4 Excellent product with technical features and performance that provide clear and substantial benefits
- 5 Superb product that sets new standards for performance and provides groundbreaking and new technical milestones
Each product's scores were averaged and rounded to the nearest full or half Diamond. Note that products are grouped by score (with the highest Diamonds ranking first), and then in alphabetical order.
Scores of 3.5 or above are considered superlative and reflect a very positive opinion from the panel. Only products receiving 3.5 Diamonds or above are included in this article.
Diamonds Judges 2011 (in alphabetical order):
- Paul Brooks, Senior Director, Network Architecture, Time Warner Cable
- Jeff Chen, Senior VP, Advanced Technologies, Bright House
- Tom Gorman, VP, Field Operations, Charter
- Wayne Hall, VP, Engineering, Comcast
- Bob Legg, VP, Technical Operations, Suddenlink
- Ed Marchetti, VP, Engineering/Operations, Comcast
- Leslie W. Read, Consultant, Read Broadband Services
- Alan Tschirner, VP, Hardware, NCTC
- Ron Upchurch, Consultant
- Ken Williams, Director, HFC Architecture, Cox